For decades, we’ve been told that the best thing to do after an injury is rest, ice, compression and elevation. But is that still the best advice?
If you’ve ever sprained an ankle, strained a muscle or suffered a sporting injury, you’ve probably been told to follow RICE.
Rest. Ice. Compression. Elevation.
It’s one of the most recognisable approaches to injury management, used by athletes, coaches, healthcare professionals and the general public for decades.
However, our understanding of inflammation, tissue healing and rehabilitation has developed considerably since the acronym was introduced.
Even Dr Gabe Mirkin, who popularised RICE in 1978, has subsequently questioned the routine use of ice and prolonged rest.
But does that mean ice is harmful? Should we stop taking ibuprofen? And is inflammation something we should actually encourage?
The answer isn’t as simple as social media might suggest.
Let’s examine what the research tells us and, more importantly, what it means for recovering from an injury.
Inflammation Isn’t the Enemy
When you sprain an ankle or damage a muscle, your body initiates an inflammatory response.
This is a normal and necessary part of tissue healing.
Following injury, changes in blood flow and blood-vessel permeability allow immune cells and signalling molecules to reach the affected tissues.
These processes help clear damaged material and initiate repair.
It’s also why the injured area may become:
Swollen
Warm
Red
Painful
Difficult to move
For years, much of our immediate injury management focused on reducing these symptoms.
However, inflammation is not simply something that needs to be switched off. It plays an important biological role in recovery.
That doesn’t mean more inflammation is always better.
Excessive swelling can increase pain, restrict movement and interfere with function.
The objective is to manage the injury appropriately while allowing normal healing processes to occur.
Does Ice Actually Help an Injury Heal?
Ice has traditionally been used to reduce pain and swelling following acute injuries.
And there is a reason it remains popular.
Cooling can temporarily reduce pain by affecting nerve conduction and local tissue temperature.
For someone with a painful ankle sprain, that may provide welcome short-term relief.
But here’s the important distinction.
Reducing pain is not the same as accelerating tissue healing.
Experimental research suggests that substantial cooling can influence inflammatory signalling and aspects of tissue repair.
However, much of this evidence comes from animal or laboratory studies.
We cannot automatically assume that applying an ice pack to a human ankle for a short period produces the same effects.
Clinical research has not established that brief, appropriately applied icing causes worse long-term healing.
Equally, convincing evidence that routine icing accelerates ligament repair or improves long-term outcomes is limited.
So the conclusion is not that ice is always harmful.
It’s that ice should be viewed primarily as a possible short-term pain-management tool, rather than an essential treatment that makes tissues heal faster.
If someone finds brief cooling helpful, it can be considered as part of symptom management, provided the skin is protected and cold-related risks are taken into account.
But repeatedly icing an injury while neglecting movement and rehabilitation is unlikely to produce the best outcome.
What About Ibuprofen and Anti-Inflammatory Medication?
Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, commonly known as NSAIDs, include medications such as ibuprofen.
They are frequently used to manage pain and inflammation following musculoskeletal injuries.
Research shows that NSAIDs can provide short-term pain relief and, in some circumstances, improvements in early function.
However, inflammatory pathways are also involved in tissue repair.
This has led researchers to investigate whether suppressing inflammation might influence healing.
Some experimental studies suggest that particular anti-inflammatory interventions can affect tissue regeneration.
But the findings are not consistent across different tissues, injuries, medications and treatment durations.
There is not sufficient clinical evidence to claim that taking ibuprofen after a sprained ankle inevitably delays recovery or causes chronic pain.
There are, however, recognised risks associated with NSAIDs, particularly with higher doses or prolonged use.
These include gastrointestinal bleeding, kidney complications and cardiovascular risks in susceptible individuals.
Medication decisions should therefore reflect the individual, the injury and appropriate medical or pharmaceutical advice.
Pain management can be valuable, particularly when it improves sleep, comfort and participation in rehabilitation.
The important point is that medication should not replace the rehabilitation process.
Why Prolonged Rest Can Delay Recovery
Perhaps the most important change in modern injury rehabilitation concerns rest.
Following an acute injury, a short period of protection may be necessary.
This can prevent further damage and allow symptoms to settle.
However, prolonged or unnecessary immobilisation can have consequences.
Muscles lose strength.
Joints become stiff.
Movement confidence decreases.
And the injured area can become less tolerant of the physical demands placed upon it.
Our musculoskeletal system adapts to mechanical loading.
Muscles, tendons, ligaments and bones all respond to the stresses they experience.
This is why progressive loading is such an important component of rehabilitation.
The challenge is not simply to avoid loading an injured tissue. It’s to identify the appropriate amount of loading at the appropriate stage of recovery.
Too much, too soon can aggravate an injury.
Too little, for too long can contribute to deconditioning.
Effective rehabilitation requires finding the balance.
From RICE to PEACE and LOVE
In 2019, Blaise Dubois and Jean-François Esculier proposed an alternative framework for managing soft-tissue injuries.
They called it PEACE and LOVE.
The framework encourages clinicians and patients to think beyond immediate symptom relief and consider the entire recovery process.
PEACE: Immediate Injury Management
P — Protect
Temporarily reduce activities that substantially aggravate symptoms, while avoiding unnecessary prolonged rest.
E — Elevate
Elevation may help manage swelling and discomfort.
A — Avoid anti-inflammatories
Consider whether routine anti-inflammatory strategies are necessary, recognising the role of inflammation in healing and the limitations of the available evidence.
C — Compress
Compression may provide support and assist with swelling management.
E — Educate
Help people understand their injury, expected recovery and the importance of active rehabilitation.
LOVE: The Rehabilitation Process
L — Load
Gradually introduce appropriate mechanical loading as symptoms and tissue capacity allow.
O — Optimism
Address fear, uncertainty and negative expectations that may influence recovery.
V — Vascularisation
Introduce suitable cardiovascular exercise to maintain conditioning and support general health.
E — Exercise
Restore mobility, strength, balance, coordination and functional performance.
PEACE and LOVE is a useful framework, although it should not be mistaken for a treatment protocol proven superior for every injury.
Its central message is valuable:
Recovery requires more than reducing pain and swelling. It requires rebuilding physical capacity.
What Should You Actually Do After Spraining an Ankle?
An ankle sprain is a useful example of how modern rehabilitation works.
First, the injury needs to be assessed appropriately.
Not every swollen ankle is a simple ligament sprain. Fractures, syndesmotic injuries and significant instability may require medical assessment, imaging or a different management approach.
For an uncomplicated ankle sprain, rehabilitation generally involves several stages.
1. Protect and Support
During the initial stages, temporary activity modification, compression or an ankle brace may be appropriate.
The amount of protection required depends on the severity of the injury.
More significant injuries may require restricted weight-bearing or immobilisation under clinical guidance.
2. Restore Movement
As symptoms permit, gradually reintroduce movement and weight-bearing.
This may begin with simple ankle movements and progress towards comfortable walking.
The objective is to restore normal movement without repeatedly provoking substantial increases in symptoms.
3. Rebuild Strength
Progressive resistance training becomes increasingly important.
Exercises may include:
Calf raises
Resisted ankle movements
Squats
Step-ups
Split squats
Single-leg strengthening exercises
The aim is not simply to strengthen the ankle in isolation.
It’s to rebuild the capacity of the entire lower limb.
4. Restore Balance and Control
Ankle injuries can affect proprioception, balance and neuromuscular control.
Rehabilitation should progressively challenge these qualities through appropriate balance and single-leg exercises.
5. Prepare for Return to Activity
Being able to walk comfortably doesn’t necessarily mean you’re ready to run, jump or play sport.
Later rehabilitation may include hopping, landing, acceleration, deceleration and changes of direction.
The exercises should reflect the demands of the activity the individual wants to return to.
Progression should be based on symptoms, strength, movement quality and functional performance, rather than simply the number of weeks since injury.
Pain Relief Isn’t the Same as Rehabilitation
This is something I regularly emphasise at Poseidon Performance.
An injury can stop hurting before the affected tissues have regained their previous physical capacity.
Someone recovering from an ankle sprain might walk without discomfort but still have reduced calf strength, poor balance or difficulty tolerating running.
Similarly, someone recovering from a knee injury may feel comfortable during everyday activities but struggle with squatting, stairs or returning to sport.
These problems require physical reconditioning.
Massage, ice, medication and other symptom-management strategies may have a role.
But they do not automatically restore strength, balance, coordination or tolerance to load.
An injury isn’t necessarily fully rehabilitated simply because the pain has disappeared.
The objective should be to restore the person’s ability to tolerate the physical demands of their life.
Injury Rehabilitation in Dartmouth: A Strength-Based Approach
At Poseidon Performance in Dartmouth, South Devon, rehabilitation focuses on assessment, progressive exercise and individualised strength development.
Whether someone is recovering from a sporting injury, managing persistent joint pain or returning to activity following surgery, the underlying principles remain consistent.
We establish what the individual can currently tolerate.
We identify the physical qualities that need improving.
And we progressively rebuild the strength, movement confidence and capacity required for their goals.
For one person, that might mean walking comfortably again.
For another, it could mean returning to tennis, running, lifting weights or Brazilian Jiu Jitsu.
The programme should reflect the individual, their injury and the demands they need to meet.
Because effective rehabilitation shouldn’t simply make someone feel better while resting.
It should prepare them to return to the activities that matter.
The Bottom Line: Should We Stop Using RICE?
Traditional RICE isn’t entirely useless.
Temporary rest, compression and elevation can still have a place in managing an acute injury.
Ice may also provide short-term pain relief.
But the idea that reducing inflammation and resting an injury are the primary ingredients for successful recovery is outdated.
Inflammation plays a necessary role in healing.
Unnecessary prolonged rest can contribute to deconditioning.
And appropriately progressed movement and strength training are fundamental components of rehabilitation.
The important question is no longer simply:
How do we reduce the pain and swelling?
It’s also:
How do we rebuild the strength, control and physical capacity needed to return to normal activity?
That’s the difference between managing an injury and rehabilitating it.
Assess. Rebuild. Strengthen. Return to life.
Injury Rehabilitation at Poseidon Performance
If you’re recovering from an injury or struggling to return to your usual activities, Poseidon Performance provides individual exercise-based rehabilitation and strength coaching in Dartmouth, Devon.
Our approach combines assessment, progressive loading and practical rehabilitation to help you rebuild confidence and physical capacity.
Find out more or book an initial assessment at:
References
Dubois B, Esculier JF. Soft-tissue injuries simply need PEACE and LOVE. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2020;54:72–73. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2019-101253
Bleakley CM, McDonough SM, MacAuley DC. The use of ice in the treatment of acute soft-tissue injury: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials. American Journal of Sports Medicine. 2004;32(1):251–261.
Vuurberg G, et al. Diagnosis, treatment and prevention of ankle sprains: update of an evidence-based clinical guideline. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2018;52:956.
Martin RL, et al. Ankle Stability and Movement Coordination Impairments: Lateral Ankle Ligament Sprains Revision 2021. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy. 2021;51(4):CPG1–CPG80.
Mirkin G. Why Ice Delays Recovery. 2014. Commentary reconsidering the original RICE recommendations.
This article provides general educational information and is not a substitute for individual medical assessment. Suspected fractures, severe injuries, significant instability or worsening symptoms require appropriate clinical evaluation. Follow your surgeon’s specific instructions after an operation.